It is a “nuanced view of gender.” It avoids rigid gender stereotypes, even as it acknowledges that “gender norms” are not merely “social constructs.”Ĭhapter 8 concludes the book by examining transgender identity from the standpoint of public policy. Because of this, Anderson argues, “We need medical professionals who will help them mature in harmony with their bodies, rather than deploy experimental treatments to refashion their bodies.”Ĭhapter 7 outlines a view of gender that Anderson believes is preferable to transgender identity theory. Experts agree that between 80 and 95 percent of kids who experience gender dysphoria naturally resolve those feelings in favor of their biological sex. ![]() “The central debate in treating people with gender dysphoria is whether therapies should focus primarily on the mind or on the body,” writes Anderson, who argues that treating the feeling of incongruity between biological sex and gender identity has better therapeutic outcomes than gender reassignment.Ĭhapter 6 examines gender dysphoria among children. ![]() Anderson understands it as “incongruence between biological sex and experienced gender.” How one defines gender dysphoria determines how one treats it. Anderson reminds readers how radical it is.Ĭhapter 4 examines “what science tells us about the biological basis of sex.” Anderson writes, “The fundamental conceptual distinction between a male and a female is the organism’s organization for sexual reproduction.” Indeed, he argues that “sex is a coherent concept only on the basis of that organization.”Ĭhapter 5 then explores the nature and treatment of gender dysphoria. Anderson argues that these stories “tell us, at minimum, that transitioning is not the ‘only solution’ to gender dysphoria.” Popular culture and political action may have normalized transgender identity, but Ryan T. When Harry Became Sally offers a multidisciplinary critique of transgender identity.Ĭhapters 1 and 2 describe our transgender moment and the ideology of transgender activists, respectively.Ĭhapter 3 then turns to the personal narratives of transgender people who subsequently detransitioned to their birth sex. This is a metaphysical claim, one that needs to be subjected to more scrutiny than it has been. A transgender boy is a boy, not merely a girl who identifies as a boy.” Popular culture and political action may have normalized transgender identity, but Anderson reminds readers how radical it is: “At the heart of the transgender moment are radical ideas about the human person - in particular, that people are what they claim to be, regardless of contrary evidence. (The Trump administration reversed many of these executive actions.) The Department of Health and Human Services (2016) similarly proposed expanding the meaning of sex to include “gender identity.” Various federal laws ban discrimination based on sex (e.g., Title IX), but Obama administration actions required schools and hospitals to act as if there were no legal difference between a biological female and a biological male who identifies as a woman. In a series of “Dear Colleague” letters, first the Department of Education (2010) and then the Department of Justice and Department of Education jointly (2016) redefined the word sex - i.e., biological sex - to include “gender identity.” Jenner’s transition put a well-known face on America’s transgender moment, but actions by the Obama administration gave the moment legal muscle. ![]() In October, Glamour magazine named Jenner a “Woman of the Year.” A judge legally approved Jenner’s name and gender change in September of that year. The inflection point was probably Diane Sawyer’s April 2015 interview with Bruce Jenner, in which he said, “for all intents and purposes I’m a woman,” taking the name Caitlyn a few months later. “Not long ago, most Americans had never heard of transgender identity, but within the space of a year it became a cause claiming the mantle of civil rights.” America is in the midst of what has been called a ‘transgender moment,’” writes Ryan T.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |